Georges Bernanos was a Catholic writer acclaimed for his novel Under the Sun of Satan – the story of a disillusioned priest. He arrived in Majorca in 1934, weary of Parisian literary squabbles and politics. The Mediterranean light, he thought, would heal him.
GEORGES BERNANOS
He rented a house near Palma surrounded by olive trees and the dry drum of cicadas, a perfect exile for writing and contemplation. Spain was for Bernanos a deeply Catholic land – pious, warm, poor but proud – a place where the faith of his French childhood in Pas-de-Calais still lived.
Two years later, his peace was shattered. The uprising of July 1936 turned the island into one of Franco’s first laboratories of terror. The churches that had once offered sanctuary now echoed with gunfire and screams. Night after night, trucks carried prisoners to the cemetery walls and left them there, bleeding into the earth.
Bernanos sympathised with the Nationalist cause, believing it to be a defence against anarchist chaos. It did not take long before he saw the truth. The men he met in Palma’s cafés – priests, officers, respectable families – spoke of executions with calm indifference. They congratulated themselves on the purification of Spain. This wasn’t a civil war. It was a holy crusade.
‘What I saw in Majorca,’ he wrote, ‘was the triumph of hatred, the stifling of charity in Christian hearts.’ He watched as priests blessed soldiers before they stood ordinary working men and women before the cemetery wall and shot them. As the good Catholics they considered themselves, massacres were justified in the name of the Church.
‘The cross of Christ,’ he said bitterly, ‘was now carried by firing squads.’
Broken Traditions
It was a revelation that broke him apart. He had always been a conservative, a defender of tradition and faith against modern corruption. But what he witnessed in Spain was not faith – it was fanaticism wrapped in liturgy. He saw that the Church, by siding with Franco, had betrayed the Gospel it claimed to serve.
This did not justify the destruction of churches and the murder of priests, but it did explain it. The church where the people had been baptised, married and buried was the fulcrum around which their lives turned. Every fiesta and celebration had a saint’s name tied to it. The vast majority of Spaniards were believers and they found it hard to believe or understand when the very shepherd of their soul turned to Franco and betrayed them.
When Bernanos published Les Grands Cimetières sous la lune — The Great Cemeteries Under the Moon — in 1938, it was a cry from the soul. Written in a fever of indignation, the book described what he had seen on Majorca: the murders, the lies, the cowardice of those who knew and remained silent. It was not a political treatise but a moral confession. ‘I am a Catholic,’ he wrote, ‘and I cannot accept that the blood of innocents is the price of order.’
The book caused a scandal. In France, the Right denounced him as a traitor; the Left distrusted him because he refused to embrace their revolution. Georges Bernanos stood alone, scorning both camps. ‘I am not of the Left. I am not of the Right,’ he responded. ‘I am of the poor people crushed by both.’
Like Orwell, like many who served in the International Brigades, Bernanos came to see that the struggle in Spain was not merely between fascism and communism, but between truth and deceit, humanity and ideology. Orwell saw it from the street battles in Barcelona, Bernanos from the confessional heart of Catholic Spain. Both concluded that the deepest evil was the lie that murder can be justice, that cruelty can serve faith, that the end can sanctify and justify the means.
The Fury of Bernanos
What distinguishes Bernanos is that he turned his fury inward, toward his own Church and class. He did not excuse himself as a bystander. He accused himself of having believed too easily in authority, of mistaking respectability for virtue. His book is written in the language of repentance. Each page burns with moral anguish: how could a Christian nation turn its faith into a weapon?
After Spain, Bernanos never again believed in institutions. His faith survived, but it became a faith against power – mystical, solitary, stripped of hierarchy. During the German occupation of France, he lived in exile in Brazil and continued to write against fascism and collaboration. His letters thundered with the same indignation that had driven him to denounce Franco’s Spain. He believed that tyranny, whether draped in the flag or the cassock, was a blasphemy against human dignity.
He was, in his way, a prophet. The Church he condemned in 1938 would, decades later, recognise its complicity in Franco’s regime. But Bernanos needed no vindication. He had lived by a single principle: that conscience must never be silenced by obedience. ‘When one is afraid to disobey,’ he said, ‘one is already a slave.’
Faith and cruelty in Spain have always lived close together like two vines twisted around the same wall. In the villages of Catalonia and Aragón, remnants of that old division still exist, the devout and the anticlerical, the believers and the betrayed. Bernanos would have recognised it at once: the tragic intimacy between the sacred and the savage.
He had gone to Majorca to write novels about grace and sin, but Spain forced him to live the questions he had imagined for his characters. The horror he witnessed gave him the gift, and the curse, of moral clarity. He discovered that truth is never found in the slogans of power, but in the hearts of those who suffer.
Europe’s Conscience
When The Great Cemeteries Under the Moon appeared, André Malraux called it ‘the conscience of a defeated Spain.’ It was more than that. It was the conscience of Europe, a cry against the easy moral sleep that allowed dictators to rise. Bernanos saw that civilisation was not collapsing from barbarism, but from cowardice. ‘The modern world,’ he wrote, ‘is not short of men of faith, but of men of courage.’ It is a sentence he could have written of Europe today, in 2025.
He died in 1948, aged sixty, still railing against hypocrisy and despair. In his final essays he spoke of the poor, the powerless, the children who would inherit a broken world. He never abandoned hope, but it was the hope of a penitent, not a visionary – fragile, painful, sustained by compassion.
Bernanos had gone to Spain seeking peace and instead found the truth. That truth, the simple, terrible knowledge that goodness cannot exist without courage, marked him for life. The war made him one of the rarest of heroes: a man who changed his mind, who chose conscience over tribe, and who spoke out when silence would have been safer.
There are no statues of Georges Bernanos in Majorca, no plaques on the walls where the blood once dried. But his words remain, echoing across the years like a bell tolling through the night: a warning to believers and unbelievers alike that faith without mercy is a form of murder, and that moral courage, once abandoned, is the first casualty of every war.
You may enjoy my Spanish Civil War novel –
WE SHALL PASS is available from indy publisher Luath Press – click HERE.
And all the Amazons, paperback and Kindle – click HERE.
“The best book set during the Spanish Civil War since For Whom the Bells Tolls.” MARK DUFFIELD
“… a story of friendship, adversity and political commitment. A timely reminder, if we ever need one.” NEIL JORDAN